The new official Orkney Community Flag was the winner of a public flag consultation in February and March 2007. In the flag consultation, the people of Orkney were asked for their preferred design from a short list of 5, all of which had been approved by the Court of Lord Lyon. The chosen design was that of Duncan Tullock of Birsay, which polled 53% of the 200 votes cast by the public.
The colors red and yellow are from the Scottish and Norwegian royal coats of arms, which both use yellow and red, with a lion rampant. The flag symbolizes the islands' Scottish and Norwegian heritage. The blue is taken from the flag of Scotland and also represents the sea and the maritime heritage of the islands.
The new flag resembles the flags of Norway (white for yellow) and Aland (colors reversed). The issue of the supposed similarity with the flag of the Norwegian fascist Vidkun Quisling's party Nasjonal Samling was raised in The Orcadian in May 2007. That flag, however, did not include the blue cross, which makes the two easily distinguishable. It should also be noted that a red-yellow flag was, and still is, used by people in the Swedish province of Skane years before Nasjonal Samling used a red-yellow cross flag. A red-yellow cross flag is also used by Swedish-speaking Finns.